I've been doing a lot of listening lately. I've got a reasonably good system (see sig) and it sounds really good. But when a go to a live musical event, its obvious something is missing. Part of it is the recorded compression, lack of dynamics.
But I think what I'm not hearing in recorded music, is a certain "liveness". I wonder if live music's sound field, the room's reverberance, with all the multi-path and phase shifting of the music bouncing around the hall is what is missing from recordings. Most of our living rooms are small and dead.
If that is the problem, then 5.1 recordings should improve it.
Last Edit: Jun 25, 2016 13:13:50 GMT -5 by Priapulus
__ Theatre __ 4k Samsung 55" screen, nu8000 series 4k Samsung UBD-M9700 BluRay Player 4k HTPC XMC-1 Processor XPA-2 Amplifier - main XPA-5 Amplifier - surround
__ Record Player __ "The" AR Turntable, SME-3 arm, Shure V15-III XSP-1 Preamp Sonic Frontiers Power 2 amplifier, 16 tube, 110 watts
I think the first problem with modern recordings is that most of them are close miked in a closed in booth. Here the reflections tend to be minimized. Sometimes they'll add some fake reverb (which sounds very obvious imo). It's only when you hear some jazz or types of classical recordings do things progress out to a more natural sound.
Transports: Sony BDP 5100 Blu ray player via RCA Coax PC using Musiland Digital Times WASAPI via BNC connection -
Amp: XPA-1 gen 2 using XLR connections. Speakers: Axiom Audio m80 V3, Sennheisser HD600 headphones. two pairs 12 guage speaker cables per monoblock for biwire. Headphone amp: Basx A-100 (INCREDIBLE VALUE WITH HD600s!!)
Well to start with, unless they're 'live' recordings they're not going to, or meant to sound live. I think you're right, that a properly miced 5.1 recording has the best chance of capturing the ambience and sound field of a live recording in a particular hall. Which also means you'd have to have listened in that venue for it to sound the same, but at least the goal was to capture and reproduce the live event.
HT: XMC-1G2v3> XPA-7> B&W 805S, HTM3S, SCMS & SVS PB-1000 (7.2) | Sony XBR-85X900F | Harmony Ultimate Home 2C: XMC-1v3> PA-1> Magnepan 20.1R Sources: DirectTV HS17/C61K, Oppo UDP-203, AppleTV4K, Mac mini, Thorens TD-295 IV w/Grado Sonata> XPS-1
Computer: Focusrite 2i2> Apple Mac mini> Emotiva DC-1> Airmotive 5 / Crossfade LP2