Will this Emotiva Dirac Live Network Interface (EDLNI) require firmware updates and if so how would that be done? Do we need it send it back and have it reflashed?
I’m coming from the perspective of how EDLNI would work when Dirac Live Bass Management is rolled out for $249 or $399?
Maybe I don’t understand the functionality and what I’m asking isn’t making sense and EDLNI can handle Dirac Live Bass Management as is.
Also, I’m assuming this now needs to be manufactured, packaged and shipped. Well this explains why we weren’t offered to beta test Dirac - wouldn’t make sense and wouldn’t be possible without this interface.
What does the black box do? Do I understand correctly that there is no connection to the processor other than via Ethernet?
What could possibly have been left out of the processor architecture to necessitate a kludge like this? I've heard of "bodge wire" but this is ridiculous.
JVC DLA-RS400 projector, CIH shrink method (DIY AT screen coming soon) B&W Nautilus 804 LR, HTM1 Cen (DIY 7pi LR and 4pi Cen coming soon) Four DIY 2pi surrounds Four DIY MFW-15 sealed subs with Crown XLS 1502 Rotel power amps: two RB-991 (2chx200wpc), one RB-993 (3chx200wpc) Oppo BDP-83, HTPC Win 10 and Kodi Emotiva UMC-200 System control by iRule, Lighting control by Insteon Nakamichi System 7: CA-7a preamp, CR-7a cassette, ST-7 tuner
What does the black box do? Do I understand correctly that there is no connection to the processor other than via Ethernet?
What could possibly have been left out of the processor architecture to necessitate a kludge like this? I've heard of "bodge wire" but this is ridiculous.
Re read the first post. My take on it is the Dirac software used on the computer talks to the 'black box' and the 'black box' will talk to the processor to load all of the required filters. Integration into the new platform obviously hasn't gone 100% as planed but in reality its not that big of a deal.
PrePro: Emotiva XMC-2 (7.2) L/R Amp: Emotiva XPA-1 Gen 2's Other Amp: Emotiva XPA-5 Gen 1 L/R Speakers: Paradigm S8v3 Center Speaker: Paradigm C3v1 Side Speakers: Paradigm S6v3 Rear Speakers: Paradigm S2v3 Sub: Dual Paradigm SUB1's TV: 65 Panasonic VT50 Media: Intel NUC HTPC / Chromecast / Pioneer BluRay
What does the black box do? Do I understand correctly that there is no connection to the processor other than via Ethernet?
What could possibly have been left out of the processor architecture to necessitate a kludge like this? I've heard of "bodge wire" but this is ridiculous.
Don't use it. No one is forcing you.
Student of Psycho-acoustics. Equipment - Emotiva: RMC-1L, XDA-3, CMX-2, CMX-6. Some other stuff. Cables - Emotiva, Zeskit, Ruipro, Canare, Mogami, Belden.
Become the kind of person that when your feet hit the floor in the morning, Satan groans and says, "OH CRAP, HE'S AWAKE".
Mr. Rogers did not adequately prepare me for the people in my neighborhood.
When we started work on designing the RMC-1, and our entire line of new processors, our goal was to deliver the best possible performance and sound quality for our customers. One of the ways we chose to help us make that goal a reality was to incorporate the latest generation of powerful, cutting-edge DSP processors.
Based on the information we had when we started the project, and the fact that the Dirac software was already being incorporated into other processors that use older technology, we didn't expect it to be especially difficult to include the code required to support Dirac Live automatic room correction into our new line of processors. Unfortunately, that turned out not to be the case, and integrating Dirac Live into the RMC-1 family turned out to be a much bigger project than we'd initially anticipated, which has been the reason for all the delays. The final result of our labor has been the development of a small external hardware module, the Emotiva Dirac Live Network Interface, which facilitates communication between our processor and the Dirac Live software installed on your computer. It is a small device, with its own processor and code, that is connected to your network when you perform your Dirac Live room calibrations on your processor. It only has to be connected to your network when you're actually taking measurements, or using the Dirac software to create a new Dirac Live profile, and doesn't have to be connected when you're simply using your processor. Since it is an integral part of using Dirac Live with your RMC-1, RMC-1L, or XMC-2 processor, we will be providing it to our customers at no charge as part of the Dirac Live calibration package that comes with your unit. (Customers who have already received their processor will receive the new hardware at the same time as their Dirac Live license.)
Connecting the device to your network is very simple, it won't take up much space in your closet when you're not using it, we think the results are worth it, and we're sure you'll agree.
The Emotiva Processor Development Team
Hi Nick. Will you ship this for free to all users including countries outside of US.
What does the black box do? Do I understand correctly that there is no connection to the processor other than via Ethernet?
What could possibly have been left out of the processor architecture to necessitate a kludge like this? I've heard of "bodge wire" but this is ridiculous.
Don't use it. No one is forcing you.
They haven't confirmed this, but it seems pretty clear that code development for their chosen DSP was more difficult and costly than building a small platform that already has code and services support. It isn't so much "what was left out" as it is "how to integrate". Just be glad they figured out a way to get it out, because my fear was constant misery of code revisions to integrate their DSP with Dirac.
Emotiva Gear: RMC-1 XPA-5 Gen 2 XPA-Four Gen 3 (Stereo Modules) C1 T1s (3) Pair of A1s CX-6 Power Strip
Other Gear: Klipsch RF-83s with all matching speakers for 7.1 Surround sound. Marantz 8002 Receiver Rotel 1080 Amp MiniDSP 2x4 and Art Clean boxes (2) Class D Sub Amps (2) 12 inch TC Sounds LMS-R (4) 18 inch Subs - FI Audio IB318 (Infinite Baffle) HTPC (Jriver and MPC running MadVR) Xbox One X Visio 65 inch M series
They haven't confirmed this, but it seems pretty clear that code development for their chosen DSP was more difficult and costly than building a small platform that already has code and services support. It isn't so much "what was left out" as it is "how to integrate". Just be glad they figured out a way to get it out, because my fear was constant misery of code revisions to integrate their DSP with Dirac.
Emotiva relied on promises others made. They went for sound quality and achieved that, with some possible minor software issues still in the way of complete stability, and now are integrating a solution to keep sound quality and implement Dirac. It's a win-win, with a lot of work behind it.
Student of Psycho-acoustics. Equipment - Emotiva: RMC-1L, XDA-3, CMX-2, CMX-6. Some other stuff. Cables - Emotiva, Zeskit, Ruipro, Canare, Mogami, Belden.
Become the kind of person that when your feet hit the floor in the morning, Satan groans and says, "OH CRAP, HE'S AWAKE".
Mr. Rogers did not adequately prepare me for the people in my neighborhood.
They haven't confirmed this, but it seems pretty clear that code development for their chosen DSP was more difficult and costly than building a small platform that already has code and services support. It isn't so much "what was left out" as it is "how to integrate". Just be glad they figured out a way to get it out, because my fear was constant misery of code revisions to integrate their DSP with Dirac.
Emotiva relied on promises others made. They went for sound quality and achieved that, with some possible minor software issues still in the way of complete stability, and now are integrating a solution to keep sound quality and implement Dirac. It's a win-win, with a lot of work behind it.
I agree. It is less than ideal for them I'd say, but I see it as a good thing as well. As long as there is no loss of functionality.
Emotiva Gear: RMC-1 XPA-5 Gen 2 XPA-Four Gen 3 (Stereo Modules) C1 T1s (3) Pair of A1s CX-6 Power Strip
Other Gear: Klipsch RF-83s with all matching speakers for 7.1 Surround sound. Marantz 8002 Receiver Rotel 1080 Amp MiniDSP 2x4 and Art Clean boxes (2) Class D Sub Amps (2) 12 inch TC Sounds LMS-R (4) 18 inch Subs - FI Audio IB318 (Infinite Baffle) HTPC (Jriver and MPC running MadVR) Xbox One X Visio 65 inch M series
I recently purchased a second-hand, NIB XMC-2 over on AVS and the seller emailed my info to Emotiva for the warranty transfer. Will I receive the "little black box" or will it be sent to the original owner or neither? Thanks!
I recently purchased a second-hand, NIB XMC-2 over on AVS and the seller emailed my info to Emotiva for the warranty transfer. Will I receive the "little black box" or will it be sent to the original owner or neither? Thanks!
You are obviously going to want to email and/or call support with your serial number and information. Stay in front of it. Don't rely on this board for any firm answers for things like this.
Emotiva Gear: RMC-1 XPA-5 Gen 2 XPA-Four Gen 3 (Stereo Modules) C1 T1s (3) Pair of A1s CX-6 Power Strip
Other Gear: Klipsch RF-83s with all matching speakers for 7.1 Surround sound. Marantz 8002 Receiver Rotel 1080 Amp MiniDSP 2x4 and Art Clean boxes (2) Class D Sub Amps (2) 12 inch TC Sounds LMS-R (4) 18 inch Subs - FI Audio IB318 (Infinite Baffle) HTPC (Jriver and MPC running MadVR) Xbox One X Visio 65 inch M series
I recently purchased a second-hand, NIB XMC-2 over on AVS and the seller emailed my info to Emotiva for the warranty transfer. Will I receive the "little black box" or will it be sent to the original owner or neither? Thanks!
It would probably come to you, as long as the warranty has been transferred. However, it would be best to give them a call to confirm this, and ensure that they have your shipping address correct and attached to your own black box. It seems like an easy thing that is worth doing, as a precaution, to forestall any possibility of unwanted "human" error in this case.
PS : I see that megash0n beat me to it. I agree with him completely, of course.
Yeah, that was a dumb question to ask here. Just got a little excited I guess lol. I’ll definitely follow up directly with Emotiva. Thanks!
I don't think it was dumb at all, and I hope my response didn't come off as harsh or prickish. My only point was that it matters not what any of us say. Even Emotiva commenting on here. Be safe and go directly to the source.
Emotiva Gear: RMC-1 XPA-5 Gen 2 XPA-Four Gen 3 (Stereo Modules) C1 T1s (3) Pair of A1s CX-6 Power Strip
Other Gear: Klipsch RF-83s with all matching speakers for 7.1 Surround sound. Marantz 8002 Receiver Rotel 1080 Amp MiniDSP 2x4 and Art Clean boxes (2) Class D Sub Amps (2) 12 inch TC Sounds LMS-R (4) 18 inch Subs - FI Audio IB318 (Infinite Baffle) HTPC (Jriver and MPC running MadVR) Xbox One X Visio 65 inch M series
What could possibly have been left out of the processor architecture to necessitate a kludge like this? I've heard of "bodge wire" but this is ridiculous.
What an odd reaction to this news. Keep in mind, Emotiva was one of the first brands to produce a platform compatible with Dirac. Since they settled on their platform, Dirac released Dirac 2.0, which obviously changed the landscape under Emotiva's feet. Rather than scrap everything and start over, they found a different solution. Now, if it doesn't work well, then negativity and criticism will be well-founded. If everything integrates well, then who cares?
Yeah, that was a dumb question to ask here. Just got a little excited I guess lol. I’ll definitely follow up directly with Emotiva. Thanks!
I don't think it was dumb at all, and I hope my response didn't come off as harsh or prickish. My only point was that it matters not what any of us say. Even Emotiva commenting on here. Be safe and go directly to the source.
I didn’t take it that way at all. I took it as friendly, good advice. From what I seen so far, this board is loaded with a bunch of great people. I look forward to learning from you guys. Thanks again.
They haven't confirmed this, but it seems pretty clear that code development for their chosen DSP was more difficult and costly than building a small platform that already has code and services support.
Emotiva stated above that this new interface would only be required during the measurement and communication phase with the Dirac servers. It can be removed once the filters have been calculated and downloaded to the AVP.
To me this indicates the interface box is in addition to and not a replacement for DSP code development. The DSP is still very much in the driver's seat when it comes to processing the audio using the pre calculated EQ filters.
It's more likely the interface box was required as the measurement and/or communication cycle with Dirac servers proved too taxing for the CPU, DSP and/or communication bus in the AVP. This of course is per speculation and based on nothing more than an educated guess.
I am pleased for all current owners of the RMC family of processors that it looks like Emotiva have found a way to deliver Dirac but it is of some concern to me as a prospective buyer that an external interface such as this is required.
I hope Emotiva can share with us what it is that this interface actually does.